Saturday, November 17, 2012
Afterthoughts on Election 2012
I didn’t comment much on the election, partly because I didn’t want to add to the noise, noise, noise, noise. Like many people, I assumed things would quiet down after the election. But I’ve been disturbed by some of the things I’ve been hearing, so I’m writing a response.
Actually, I began thinking about this long before the election, when it looked like the result could go against the President, whom I was supporting. I felt pretty strongly about that support and wondered what I would do if Romney was elected. Then I remembered a long-ago election....
Kathy and I had really thrown ourselves into the campaign (whose campaign it was doesn’t matter). We housed a campaign worker in our home, we made phone calls, we offered rides to the polls, we volunteered at the local party headquarters. That’s where we were on election night when the results started coming in, and it became clear early on that it was a landslide in favor of the other guy.
So we all started grumbling, and our grumbling took the form of variations on “how could people be so stupid as to vote for _____________?” But one of the volunteers stopped us. He taught history and political science at the local high school and had been a party activist for years. “No,” he said. “You’ve got to trust the electorate.”
And of course he was right. That is fundamental to our political system, to our American way of life: the electorate can be trusted. We, the people, can be trusted. Sure, sometimes we’ve elected some presidents who were pretty marginal, and a few real clunkers (fill in your favorite here). But that’s one reason we have a congress. We don’t trust one person, or even a small group of people, with all the power. Most of the time, the system works. The president who is elected is the one who is best able to convince the electorate—to convince most of us—that he or she is the man or woman for the job. Individual reasons for voting may not always be reasonable, but when all the votes are counted, the only proper response is to trust the process, and that means trusting the electorate.
But ever since the election I’ve been hearing voices saying, in essence, that the electorate can’t be trusted, that the majority didn’t really understand the issues, or, worse, that they were motivated only by what they could get out of the President and not by the good of the country. National commentators have made blatantly racist statements, that whites aren’t the majority anymore, so we can expect people of color, who aren’t as responsible, to drive the electoral process. This is wrong. This is untrue. This is offensive.
I’m 62 years old. I’ve lived through several elections. I survived the presidency of Richard Nixon. I’ve seen a lot of nasty campaigning. But I believe this is the first time I’ve seen the losing party and its allies refuse to acknowledge that the thing to do now is to work with the President, who has the support of a majority of the people in the country. I believe this is the first time I’ve seen the losing candidate casting aspersions on the man he couldn’t unseat. Every other losing candidate, Democratic or Republican, most recently John McCain, has been gracious in defeat, at least in public, wishing the newly-elected President well.
I think this is what is happening: each of us cares passionately about certain issues. We have become so convinced of our own position that we believe that any right-thinking person should agree with us. If we find someone who doesn’t agree with us, that person must be a.) uninformed b.) stupid or c.) evil.
I know this attitude is real, because I’ve seen it in myself. But I realize that if I persist in that attitude, I can’t see what might be right about my opponent’s views, or what might be wrong or short-sighted about mine. I’ve changed my opinion on several issues over the years. I’d better be prepared to change them again.
I supported President Obama, but I know there were good reasons for supporting Mitt Romney. That’s how the system is supposed to work: both candidates put their ideas and their experience out there and then let us decide.
Stay passionate about your issues. But don’t demonize people on the other side. That doesn’t get anyone anywhere, and it certainly isn’t good for the country.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)